District 9, Sopranos: Do not fear nuance
District 9, Sopranos: Do not fear nuance
by Michael Falco, digital initiatives strategist
I have a slight addiction (as if there are degrees of addiction) to broadcast and on-screen entertainment — well, really, all media. This week I finished re-watching the entire “Sopranos” series and followed it up the next day with the film “District 9.” Now, admittedly, it is a real stretch to draw any parallels between the two works, but there was one overarching idea that continues to weigh on me. It relates to the notion that works of fiction continue to more accurately encapsulate the present zeitgeist than non-fiction. Sure, on the surface “The Sopranos” could simply be viewed as a shoot-em up mob series and “District 9″ as a stunning piece of science fiction. But that does an incredible disservice to what actually lies before us. I am confident that one day “The Sopranos” will be viewed as one of the most important examinations and cultural documents of American life at the turn of the century. It relentlessly approached the issues that continue to define this country, whether it is race, class mobility, sexuality, paternalism, war, violence, or post 9/11 hysteria. “District 9″ and its commentary on Apartheid South Africa is anything but subtle. But there are certainly richer layers beyond that, as the film delves into corporate greed; mass immigration; the inherent difficulties of large peace/keeping and humanitarian missions; popular public opinion trumping what is right; and xenophobia. (Although I agree with Daniel Engber over at Slate that the film could have taken the social commentary even further). The big lesson here is simply that we should never underestimate our audience. It is easy to boil things down to vacuous, one-dimensional stories like “Transformers,” but we risk doing a real disservice to our audience. I am not belittling talking points, as they often simplify complex issues to foster greater understanding. However, we should not be afraid of nuance. We should not fear creating media and messages that contain layers and that eagerly delve into the topics of our times.




